Mastering Bacon: How To Tell When Bacon Is Done

You know, bacon is a real crowd-pleaser in my household. With three rambunctious boys, it’s practically a household staple. But here’s the catch – I’ve always loathed the messy process of pan-frying bacon and dealing with all that grease.  And one of the biggest issues, how to tell when bacon is done.

That is, until I was introduced to this game-changing trick while preparing bacon for my husband’s catering events.  It was a revelation, to the the least! Now I know how to tell when bacon is done without making a mess.

Now, I am eager to share this bacon-cooking secret with you.  Watch our tutorial for all the juicy details, or keep reading for step-by-step instructions. Trust me, you’ll never go back to pan-frying bacon again. And, even if you do, you will know how to tell when bacon is done.

Alright, let’s get real here – giving you an exact cooking time for your bacon is a bit tricky. You see, bacon comes in all shapes and sizes. From those thin strips that sizzle up in no time to the hefty slices I prefer, each requires its own cooking time. Plus, even within the realm of thick-cut bacon, sizes can vary.

So, while I can’t offer you a one-size-fits-all cooking time, I can guide you on how to judge how to tell when bacon is done based on your bacon’s thickness and size. Let’s embrace the bacon diversity, shall we?

Before we dive into the cooking process, let’s go over a few essential tips for cooking bacon. 

Firstly, prioritize quality when selecting your bacon.

Opt for bacon from a trusted meat supplier or butcher shop. 

Next up, let’s talk bacon thickness.

Regular cut bacon typically ranges from 16 to 20 slices per pound, while thick-cut bacon falls between 10 to 16 pieces per pound. Now, here’s the thing – the difference between 10 slices per pound and 16 slices per pound is significant. 

I’m a big fan of thick-cut bacon, typically aiming for slices that measure around 10-12 pieces per pound.

Now, if you’re unsure about the thickness of your bacon, here’s a handy trick: count the number of slices in the package and take note of the package’s weight in pounds. For example, if you have a 1-pound package of bacon with 16 slices, you’re likely dealing with a thinner slice rather than thick-cut.  Make sense?

Thirdly, it’s always a good idea to bake extra bacon to have on hand for later.

Store the leftovers in the refrigerator or freezer for convenient reheating whenever you need them. Additionally, plan ahead by baking your bacon in advance, whether it’s the day before or even up to a week ahead.

This proactive approach ensures a seamless serving experience, particularly when catering to larger groups. Trust me, having pre-cooked bacon ready to go will make your life so much easier!

Now, I understand that everyone has their own preferences when it comes to cooking meat. So, I’m going to share with you my go-to method for serving bacon to a crowd.

With frequent brunches at my place, where I feed around 20-50 hungry teenagers each time, bacon is always the star of the show.

I’ll walk you through how I prepare it for these gatherings. This is how my husband serves it at his catering events.

So once again, while I’d love to give you a precise cooking time, it’s more helpful to focus on visual and textural cues to determine doneness. I’ll provide some general guidelines to help you gauge when your bacon is just right.

Alright… lets get right to it.  

First things first, preheat your oven.

I typically set mine to 425 degrees Fahrenheit. Now, it’s important to note that all ovens are different, so while 425 degrees works for me, it might not be the perfect temperature for yours.

If you find that your bacon is cooking too quickly and unevenly—burning on the edges but still undercooked in the middle—consider lowering the oven temperature by about 25 degrees and see how it goes.

If, on the other hand, your bacon is taking too long to cook, you may need to raise the temperature in 25-degree increments. It’s all about finding that sweet spot for perfectly cooked bacon!

Next up, grab a sheet pan and cover it with heavy-duty foil.

I prefer using the long, heavy-duty foil to ensure it covers the entire pan. You can typically find this type of foil at any grocery store, warehouse club like Costco or Sam’s Club, or you can easily purchase it online. It’s worth the extra effort for easier cleanup.

Now, here’s a handy trick: when laying out the foil, be sure to leave a little extra hanging over the edges. This will come in handy when it’s time to drain off the bacon grease.

Carefully press the foil into the corners of the pan, being mindful not to create any holes. While small holes won’t necessarily ruin your bacon, they can make cleanup a bit more challenging.

 To save time and effort, I like to prep multiple pans with foil in advance, so I don’t have to repeat this step later on.

Once the pans are prepped, it’s time to gear up!

I always reach for my disposable gloves, particularly when handling meat. It’s a habit I picked up from my days working in commercial kitchens—it just makes everything cleaner and more hygienic.

 Of course, if you prefer, you can absolutely use clean hands instead. Now, onto the bacon! I’m using a half sheet pan for this, aiming to fit about 12-14 slices of bacon on each pan.

To maximize space and efficiency, I like to bend the bacon slightly and create a few bumps while laying it out on the pan.

Not only does this method allow for more bacon to fit on each tray, but it also adds a nice visual appeal once it’s cooked. It’s also easy to know how to tell when your bacon is done.

When I am cooking a lot of bacon, I prep the uncooked bacon on as many trays as I think I need. This keeps the bacon rotating through the oven, eliminating the downtime of preparing additional trays between cooking.

Also, I will try and bake as many trays as I can at a time so that I can reduce the amount of time I spend waiting. Who likes waiting? 

After I have my trays ready to go, I throw the bacon in the oven.

Most ovens are going to have 2-3 racks that you can cook on. If you are using a conventional oven, you will have to rotate the oven every few minutes so they get even heat.

If you are using a convection oven, you most likely will not have to rotate your trays. After the first set of trays go in the oven, I set a timer for about 7-10 min.

While the bacon is cooking, I prepare the container I’ll use once it’s done.

For serving a large group all at once, I prefer a disposable aluminum foil pan. If storing bacon for later, I use a plate to drain grease. Then, I bag it up for storage.

Regardless of the container, I always line the bottom with paper towels to absorb excess grease.

When my timer goes off, I rotate the trays if I have multiple baking. 

I check and if the bacon isn’t done (which it most likely won’t be) I set a new timer for another 5-10 min. Oftentimes I start to clean up the kitchen while I wait.

After giving the bacon another check, I make it a habit to peek inside the oven every few minutes to ensure it’s cooking just right. In my eyes, burning bacon is a culinary sin we want to avoid at all costs! You have to know how to tell when bacon is done!

So now… Here’s the real secret to baking and cooking and knowing how to tell when your bacon is done:

It’s not just about following time and temperature to the letter. It’s about understanding that these guidelines are just that—guidelines. So, lets talk about how to tell when the bacon is done.  

Feel free to experiment and make adjustments to suit your taste and preferences. That’s where the real magic happens in the kitchen!

How to tell when bacon is done:

When bacon reaches its perfect doneness, it might deceive you into thinking it needs more time. Much like cookies, it continues to cook on the pan even after being removed from the oven. So, how do you tell when bacon is done? Here are some telltale signs:

  1. Color Change: Look for a transformation in the color of the bacon, with both the meat and fat acquiring a richer hue than the pale white they started with.
  2. Check the Bottom: Lift a piece of bacon with tongs to inspect the color on the bottom; it should also have a deeper hue.
  3. Bubbling: Expect to see bubbles forming from the grease on the pan, and possibly even on the bacon pieces themselves.
  4. Bendability: The bacon should still be bendable and flexible, indicating it will retain its texture even after cooling. If it feels a little stiff and likely to snap after cooling, it’s been cooked too long.

Once you’ve determined your bacon is cooked to perfection, take the pan from the oven. Carefully remove the bacon from the tray using tongs and transfer it onto the paper towels. 

If you plan to reuse the tray, you’ll need to drain the bacon grease first.

This is easily done if you’ve left a bit of extra foil on the end of the tray.

Shape your foil into a makeshift funnel, positioning it over a heat-safe container. Carefully pour the grease from the pan into this funnel. You can drain the grease from multiple pans into the same container. Once the grease cools down, pour it into a garbage bag or a ziplock bag and dispose of it in the garbage. This way, you can reuse the same tray. Remember not to pour grease down your sink drain. Pouring grease in the drain will solidify and potentially clog your pipes when it cools completely.

If you’re serving the bacon right away, cover foil pan and place in a warm oven at the lowest setting. This will keep the bacon warm without overcooking it. If you plan to serve the bacon later, let it cool completely. Once cooled, cover the bacon in the foil container with foil and store it in the fridge or freezer. Alternatively, you can transfer the cooled bacon to a ziplock bag lined with paper towels before refrigerating or freezing. Both methods work well and are convenient for reheating later.

Tip: When reheating bacon in your foil pan, preheat your oven to 300 degrees Fahrenheit and place the pan inside for approximately 45-60 minutes.

During the process, consider rotating or fluffing the bacon to ensure even heating without overcooking. This method helps retain the bacon’s flavor and texture while warming it thoroughly.

Bacon used to be a hassle to cook at my house, but since I learned these tricks, I feel like I can whip up bacon anytime. Whether it’s for big gatherings, quick reheats for my kids, or storing it in the freezer for later, these methods have made bacon preparation a breeze.

I hope you find them just as useful! Until next time, happy experimenting in your kitchen.

Similar Posts